If a committee can be convinced that the students work is sufficient to obtain the degree, as it is described by the university, then exactly how the thesis is constructed is secondary. A manuscript can be part of two theses as long as both students meet the coauthorship criteria. Inclusion of a single manuscript in two theses would not meet this definition, so long as each included a clear author contribution statement. I still, frequently, run into supervisors insisting that their students write theses that pretend to be solo-authored. As i recall, it didnt end well.
Dynamic ecology i conducted my phd at the same time as another student and we worked on different but closely related topics Buy now Thesis Co-Authorship Statement
We havent or at least, not entirely. It could easily (thematically) have been a chapter in in my msc thesis but it never occurred to me that this was a possibility. A second point about swedish theses is that not all of the papersmanuscripts in a thesis are necessarily first author manuscripts, all though i suspect most would be. Universities may, of course, have policies dictating how their students do it. I had never considered the inconsistency of pretending the work was all yours in the thesis (apart from some gracious acknowledgements) and afterwards publishing the research results with co-authors.
That chapter caused a lot of lets say concern due to the interaction of the committee wanting to help guide my dissertation the other coauthor disagreeing with their suggestions Thesis Co-Authorship Statement Buy now
It could easily (thematically) have been a chapter in in my msc thesis but it never occurred to me that this was a possibility. Ive written coauthored papers for which i couldnt, afterwards, remember or distinguish the separate contributions of each coauthor. This recognizes the possibility that a single manuscript could serve function in each thesis, although the two theses would build from it in different ways. Oh did this ever happen to me (the general problem, not the two-theses-one-chapter). We were always kind of curious as to how that was going to work out, as what they were doing was so different than everyone else in the same peer group.
This common chapter appeared on both our theses, and we are co-first-authors in the resulting papers Buy Thesis Co-Authorship Statement at a discount
The media, for example, have delighted in this way. I would argue that theses (whether undergraduate, masters, or phd) arent any different if anything, they might be likely to be coauthored. The different functions for the reader aspect would depend, i think, on whether were in scenario 2 or 3. That is, students need not be able to point to contributions to the coauthored chapter. Some background what that crazy thing which is german medical doctorate is about httpsforbetterscience.
Write we, just as you would for journal publication, and explain that we up front (as a footnote to each title page, or in an introductory chapter theres another question around all this, though and i think its an interesting one Buy Online Thesis Co-Authorship Statement
Except as otherwise marked, all posts are stephen b. Oh did this ever happen to me (the general problem, not the two-theses-one-chapter). Some background what that crazy thing which is german medical doctorate is about httpsforbetterscience. And of course i am assuming that theres full disclosure. One paper in two theses is not at all uncommon in sweden where i did my phd.
I can imagine it being appropriate to allow the project in both theses, or appropriate not to allow it, but either way it should have been discussed fully and clearly early on with both supervisory committees! Dear stephen, how about a md (dr med) thesis with two equal authors? Both got a doctorate, for submitting a joint thesis Buy Thesis Co-Authorship Statement Online at a discount
Being an old fuddy duddy from a bygone era, i do not like thesis chapters presented simply in publlication format. This common chapter appeared on both our theses, and we are co-first-authors in the resulting papers. It seems like the whose thesis question can be sidestepped if only first-authored papers can be included in a thesis. We shared an office during three years, worked in the same field sites and had so much convergence in our research questions that it felt logical to write a common chapter that kind of merged our interests and skills. I realize this is not the case, especially now, and that students at some universities include papers in their thesis on which they were not the lead author Thesis Co-Authorship Statement For Sale
Dynamic ecology i conducted my phd at the same time as another student and we worked on different but closely related topics. Friday links ecosystem restoration as art forgery, public science outreach vs. When it came down to the end of it the supervisor assigned the data to one of the graduate students. Im an evolutionary ecologist and entomologist at the university of new brunswick. But if we back away from the word thesis for a moment, the pervasiveness of coauthorship should surprise no one.
I realize there is also the possibility of joint first authorship (although i think this is fairly rare) if there truly was equal contribution and the paper is to be submitted with both students as equal-contributing lead authors, then that would be in my opinion the only scenario where the same paper deserves inclusion in two theses For Sale Thesis Co-Authorship Statement
Recognizing the coauthorship of thesis chapters isnt hard. I am currently doing a meta-analysis with a phd student at another university. It could easily (thematically) have been a chapter in in my msc thesis but it never occurred to me that this was a possibility. In principle i would favour 4 because of the trend for increasing collaboration you refer to (my current record very recent is 89 co-authors on a paper. In my opinion this scenario should never have been allowed by the committee.
I would hold positions 2 or 3 in your survey, depending on the context. A manuscript can be part of two theses, but only as long as each student can point to content that is uniquely their contribution Sale Thesis Co-Authorship Statement